With a semblance of a simple story of a man and woman trying to salvage their failing marriage with a weekend getaway, The One I Love challenges the realms of reality, fantasy and even genre. Critically-acclaimed Top of the Lake actress Elisabeth Moss and silent indie star Mark Duplass are a couple in this romantic dramadey who want different things and different people. She wants a new beginning and he wants another chance. An opportunity presents itself when they find out the guest house of their getaway home has warped time/space/dimension/wiggly-wobbly-timey-wimey and allows each of them to encounter an alternative version of their partners. While she gets a cooler, physically active husband with contacts and beachy hair, he gets the perfect stepford wife complacent with his every desire.
When the couple, who speak to each other more like business associates, begins to experiment with this dream house, it becomes obvious one of them is enjoying this more than the other. Her naiveté and hopefulness lend to Moss's acceptance of her alternative partner, while jealousy and doubt plague Duplass' tolerance for this strange take on couple's therapy. Then, in a peculiar twist of events, they find their doubles are no longer just a figment of their imaginations. Regardless of their origin---(robots, clones?) it's time for them to choose. Rather, for Moss's character to choose the one she loves.
You can't help but endure the turmoil Moss goes through in making this decision. Do you choose the one who cheated on you with the chance you can recreate the happy times or do you start something new that holds endless possibilities? Duplass' decision is not as complicated and you can't help but wonder who exactly first time director Charlie McDowell is pinning as the bad guy. The unforgiving wife or the stubborn husband? The film tests structural binaries society has engrained in us and turns the table on the viewers.
Despite it's unique premise, the film's erratic pace is sometimes uncomfortable, starting off very slow and flashing forward at random moments. I did feel emotionally invested in the character's decision, but the budding feminist inside me has to question why the writer decided to portray the husband as the sensible one, while his wife falls into the role of wide-eyed day dreamer.
If you had the chance, who would you choose to be the one you love?
Despite it's unique premise, the film's erratic pace is sometimes uncomfortable, starting off very slow and flashing forward at random moments. I did feel emotionally invested in the character's decision, but the budding feminist inside me has to question why the writer decided to portray the husband as the sensible one, while his wife falls into the role of wide-eyed day dreamer.
If you had the chance, who would you choose to be the one you love?